Scientific journals are an essential resource for researchers and scholars. They provide a platform for experts to share their research findings and insights with the broader community.
However, with so many different journals available, it can be difficult to know which ones to choose. When selecting a journal, it is important to consider its quality.
Are you wondering how to evaluate the quality of a journal for your publication?
Don’t worry, I’ve got you covered. In this article, I’ll break it down for you in two simple categories: quantitative and qualitative factors.
A. Quantitative factors of journal quality
Quantitative factors are measurable benchmarks that reflect a journal’s reputation and impact. These factors include ranking, impact factor (IF), acceptance rate, and metrics from ranking sites.
A1. Quartile rankings
Did you know that international journals have quartile metrics that you can find on the websites of Scimago, Scopus, or WoS? These metrics are divided into four quartiles, as follows:
- Quartile 1 (Q1): Journal with the highest ranking, which has the best international article quality.
- Quartile 2 (Q2): Journal with a good ranking.
- Quartile 3 (Q3): Journal with a fairly good ranking.
- Quartile 4 (Q4): Journal with the lowest ranking.
Journal ranking is important factor when choosing a journal to publish research findings and insights. A journal with a higher ranking shows that it has better quality and the articles published in it have undergone a rigorous peer review process.
A2. Impact metrics
There are several kinds of impact metrics, including Impact factor (IF), CiteScore (Scopus), dan Journal Citation Indicator (WoS). Though slightly different, we can use these metrics to gauge the quality and impact of scientific journals.
Impact factor (IF) is a measure of the average number of citations received by articles published in a journal over a certain period of time (usually the last two years).
For example, if a journal receives 100 citations in the last two years and publishes 50 articles in the last two years, then the impact factor of the journal is 2.
In a nutshell, the higher a journal’s impact metric, the more influential and better quality it is.
A3. Acceptance rate
Acceptance rate is the percentage of manuscripts that are accepted for publication in a journal. It varies depending on various factors, such as the journal’s reputation, field of science, and quality of the submitted articles.
Scientific journals with a high reputation generally have a lower acceptance rate than scientific journals with a low reputation. This is because a higher reputation journal usually have higher standards for the articles that are published.
In addition, the number of submissions to high-reputation journals generally reaches hundreds to thousands of articles per month. As a result, the competition is higher to publish research results in these journals.
B. Qualitative factors of journal quality
Don’t forget to consider qualitative factors when evaluating journal quality! These factors include the journal’s aim and scope, editorial board, and the quality of published articles.
B1. Aim and scope of the journal
The aim and scope is an important part of a scientific journal. It explains what kind of research the journal publishes, who the audience is, and how broad the journal is.
High-quality scientific journals generally have clear and very specific aims and scope. This will help researchers to determine if the journal is right for publishing their research results. In addition, it helps the scientific journal to attract the right contributors and readers.
B2. Editorial board
The editorial board is a group of experts responsible for evaluating and deciding whether an article is worthy of publication in their journal. They are generally composed of researchers and academics in the field of science covered by the journal.
High-quality scientific journals have editorial boards composed of competent and reputable experts. They will help ensure that the articles published in the journal are of high quality.
Besides, competent and reputable reviewers are also one of the factors that determine the quality of a journal. However, not all reputable journals display the names of their reviewers.
B3. Quality of published articles
The quality of published articles is one of the most important indicators for assessing the quality of a scientific journal. Generally, the quality of an article can be assessed from various aspects, such as research methodology, data analysis, and the conclusions drawn.
High-quality scientific journals have high standards for the articles they publish. Articles published in high-quality scientific journals have undergone a rigorous peer review process.
Benefits of knowing journal quality
By knowing the quality of a journal, then:
- Researchers can choose the right journal to publish their research results.
- Readers can read and refer to the reliable articles.
- Policymakers are assisted in making decisions about research funding and scientific publication proposals.
- Avoid predatory journals.
Note: Predatory journals are scientific journals that do not have good quality standards. These journals often exploit researchers by offering quick and easy publication, but at a high cost.
Tips to improve the journal quality
Journal editors can consider the following tips to improve the quality of their scientific journals:
- Select high-quality articles for publication.
- Improve the competence of the editorial board.
- Increase the frequency of publication.
- Increase journal promotion.
- Build partnerships with reputable international journals.
Conclusion
A reputable publisher/journal will offer a simple submission system, clear fees, rigorous peer review, and good publication results. They will also help make research results easier to find for readers by including them in bibliographic databases.
When choosing a journal to publish your research, consider its quality. But remember, journal quality is complex and depends on many factors.
Want to learn more about scientific journal quality or get help finding the right journal for your publication? Visit our service page.
